You Can't Take It with You (1938) - Critical Reviews

Synopsis

The stenographer Alice Sycamore is in love with her boss Tony Kirby, who is the vice-president of the powerful company owned by his greedy father Anthony P. Kirby. Kirby Sr. is dealing a monopoly in the trade of weapons, and needs to buy one last house in a twelve block area owned by Alice's grandparent Martin Vanderhof. However, Martin is the patriarch of an anarchic and eccentric family where the members do not care for money but for having fun and making friends. When Tony proposes Alice, she states that it would be mandatory to introduce her simple and lunatic family to the snobbish Kirbys, and Tony decides to visit Alice with his parents one day before the scheduled. There is an inevitable clash of classes and lifestyles, the Kirbys spurn the Sycamores and Alice breaks with Tony, changing the lives of the Kirby family.

Critical Acclaim

When You Can't Take It with You premiered in 1938, it was met with enthusiastic acclaim from critics and audiences alike, who celebrated its whimsical narrative and timely social commentary. Directed by Frank Capra, the film was adapted from the Pulitzer Prize-winning play by George S. Kaufman and Moss Hart, and Capra's touch was seen as elevating the material with charm and wit. Critics praised its ability to blend comedy and drama, capturing the tension between individual happiness and societal expectations, which resonated deeply during the Great Depression era.

Frank S. Nugent of The New York Times lauded the film for its "humor and humanity," noting its success in translating the stage play's essence to the screen. Variety's contemporary review highlighted Capra's adept direction and the strong performances of the ensemble cast, particularly James Stewart and Jean Arthur. In modern times, You Can't Take It with You holds an impressive approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes, reflecting its sustained critical favor. It is frequently cited for its vibrant portrayal of eccentricity and the importance of personal values over material wealth.

The film's lasting impact is evident through its enduring popularity and influence on the genre of screwball comedy. You Can't Take It with You won two Academy Awards, including Best Picture and Best Director for Capra, affirming its status as a cinematic classic. It has since been referenced in discussions of influential American films, celebrated for its optimistic message and its reflection on the American spirit. Its legacy persists as a reminder of the power of individuality and joy amidst societal pressures, cementing its place in the annals of Hollywood history.